Resurrection of the Body or Survival of the Soul?

Last week in dealing with eschatology I urged us to keep our focus on the definitive state of salvation rather than getting bogged down in discussions of transitional end time events. Whatever the transitional events turn out to be, the definitive state of salvation is eternal life in the presence of God. However there is one transitional event that the New Testament so connects to the definitive state that I need to deal with it, that is, the resurrection of the body. Though I won’t take the space in this essay to discuss it, my thinking on the resurrection has been definitively shaped by repeated reading and reflection on Paul’s great treatise on the resurrection in 1 Corinthians 15.

Everyone dies, and everyone knows it. But death means different things in different religions. For some religions and philosophies, death is merely a transition from this order to another. The higher part of the soul is freed from the body to return to the divine realm from which it came. Life in the cyclical of nature is bondage from which we need liberating and death is the way out. But for Christianity, death is not a transition to another mode of life; it is the end. Death is not the promise of liberation but the threat of annihilation. In the Christian understanding of salvation, the resurrection of the body is the central event of transition from this order to eternal life with God. Pinpointing death instead of the resurrection of the body as the transitional event, as popular religion often does, distorts and disrupts the entire Christian way of understanding the world. Let’s examine two reasons why the resurrection instead of death makes sense as the transition to eternal life.

First, God created this world, matter and nature, body and soul, and pronounced it very good. The body is not a prison, and life in this world is not a place of purgatory to which we were consigned because of our pre-incarnate sins. So, resurrection makes perfect sense as the transition from the present order in which creation is wounded and imperfect—though still good—to the healed and perfected order that God is preparing. Resurrection saves and perfects creation and affirms its created goodness. Or, to say it another way, God’s act of saving creation from death and decay and bringing it to its intended goal is called resurrection.

The promise of resurrection affirms continuity between the creation as it now exists and the new creation God will make. The new creation is not a replacement for the old one but the present creation saved and perfected. As for individual people, resurrection promises continuity between our present identity and our future selves. What good would it do for me to survive death if the part of my soul that survives has no memory of me and if my life in the body makes no ultimate difference? I have no more reason to look forward to this mode of survival than to survival of the atoms in my body after its dissolution! Who would find comfort in that? I can hope that my resurrected self (body and soul) will be expanded and illuminated and intimately united with Christ and filled with God’s Spirit. But unless there is continuity with the “I” that I am now, it makes no sense to call this transition resurrection or salvation.

Second, the bodily resurrection of Jesus Christ is the central revealing and saving event of the Christian faith. Why would God raise Jesus, body and soul, from the dead if death itself were the transition to eternal life? If Jesus had merely survived death as a spirit, he could have appeared as a ghost to his disciples to declare his innocence and to assure them of the possibility of surviving death. But God raised him from the dead! Jesus’ resurrection declared not only his innocence of the Jewish’s accusation of blasphemy and Roman charge of sedition but it also declared his victory over death. Jesus’ resurrection made God’s intention to save and perfect his creation more than a hypothesis consistent with God’s act of creation. It made it a fact in history. And this fact calls for a revolution in the way we live:

Therefore, my dear brothers and sisters, stand firm. Let nothing move you. Always give yourselves fully to the work of the Lord, because you know that your labor in the Lord is not in vain (1 Corinthians 15:55).

It is written: “I believed; therefore I have spoken.” Since we have that same spirit of faith, we also believe and therefore speak, because we know that the one who raised the Lord Jesus from the dead will also raise us with Jesus and present us with you to himself…Therefore we do not lose heart. Though outwardly we are wasting away, yet inwardly we are being renewed day by day. For our light and momentary troubles are achieving for us an eternal glory that far outweighs them all. So we fix our eyes not on what is seen, but on what is unseen, since what is seen is temporary, but what is unseen is eternal (2 Corinthians 4:13-18).

Next Time: What shall we make of the doctrine of Hell? Is it part of the gospel or an especially difficult part of the problem of evil? Should we take the language about Hell as literal or metaphorical?

5 thoughts on “Resurrection of the Body or Survival of the Soul?

  1. nokareon

    Hear, hear! When I first came to Pepperdine, I didn’t believe in the resurrection of the body at all. Everything physical was mortal, I said—all atoms have an alpha/beta particle decay expiration date, so all matter is intrinsically corrupt. Only souls could go to heaven, and even our imperfections as individual entities would be resolved as we were fully re-absorbed or re-unified into God’s essence. In other words, I was a modern day gnostic. One of my best friends at Pepperdine, well-steeped in classic Catholic theology, set me straight in my freshman year.

    Now I am passionate about defending the teaching of the resurrection of the body and its implications. Salvation is resurrection from the power of death—both physical and spiritual. The last enemy to be defeated is death. In my home Baptist church growing up, the resurrection of the body wasn’t exactly *denied*—it just wasn’t mentioned, talked about, or fleshed out enough for anyone to have a clear idea of what it meant. In my current church, my sense is that the situation is much the same. As N.T. Wright has written in Surprised by Hope, the resurrection of the body in its fullest manifestation is not a popular message in the 21st-century world. But if we are to be true to the genuine message of the Judeo-Christian worldview, this is a doctrine that we *must* maintain.

    Liked by 1 person

  2. ifaqtheology Post author

    Very well said! I think your experience is very common. There is of course much we cannot know about the soul and the soul/body relationship. There is room for speculation…as long as we do not become, as you say “modern gnostics,” denying the goodness of creation or the meaning of history in this world…not to mention the true significance of the resurrection of Jesus!


  3. Richard Constant

    hay Ron just wrote this what think you, my friend,
    first of all, I’d say, my Father knows all about time, he created IT.Second, I would say that it does not feel like it took 14.4 +/- billion years to be born. When I pass on to the true tabernacle suited for forever, with all u, to eat of the tree of life to my heart’s content. there I will be AT the final judgement, from my perception, I ain’t gonna have ANY JET lag. A moment a twinkle in the eye, so to speak.I and everyone ever created will there be transported like what Paul calls sleep from outside of time. at that point of existence,’everyone of this creation will fully realize if they Chose the Right GOD. God of SELF/ or the FATHER of JESUS OUR lord and king. I would liken where evil and chaos will go is to what I would think is a black hole into and becoming nothingness. i could expand on this although what do ya think Matt Dabbs


    1. Richard Constant

      So how ya coming with your book on atonement.
      SON of man = everyone other than the gal.4:4-5?
      if I understand Mr. FUDGE he eliminates all people prior to Abraham and promise, something like that?from Eternal Life (salvation). which doesn’t work for me.
      Heb. 11 Able is righteous.amoung others.



Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s