On my solitary walks I often turn toward reflection on the course of my life. The passing of time sheds new light on the significance of events and decisions made in our youth. In these thoughts I want to reflect on my early fascination with natural science and the discovery that led to my change of heart.
My Love of Science
My love of natural science began in my junior year of high school. I had signed up for a schedule of classes that did not include a science course. After the first day of classes, I heard some classmates discussing their first session in chemistry class. One of them said something like, “Did you hear what that teacher said? He said that the walls are frozen!” That idea intrigued me so much that I changed my schedule and added chemistry.
I loved learning about the components, combinations and causes of my experience of ordinary things in my environment. Instead of merely experiencing the sights, sounds, smells, texture, and tastes of things, I gained a sense of understanding why things affected the five senses and each other as they did. As an example, I remember learning something of the complex of chemicals that together formed the industrial mixture called creosote. It is a thick, brown, sticky derivative of coal tar used to preserve wooden railroad ties and utility poles. I was also fascinated to learn that pouring sulfuric acid (H2SO4) on common table salt (NaCl) released Hydrochloric acid gas (HCl) and sodium sulfate (NaSO4).
That, as I said, is what drew me into the sciences, which I also studied at the college level. I wanted to understand my world, not just get along within it. However, looking back I realize that what I really wanted without knowing it was to think nature, to enter into it. I wanted to think and feel my connection with the whole of creation. And at an even deeper level—which I could not have articulated at the time—I longed to experience God’s creation as an expression of his qualities and purposes, of his glory and beauty. I wanted to know, touch, and be touched by the Creator through the creation. My thirst for knowledge was in truth my search for fellowship with the Origin of all things.
After studying natural science for three years in college and without knowing exactly why, I lost my enthusiasm for the subject. I changed my plan of study, turning away from the study of nature and toward the study of God.
What is Natural Science?
I discovered much later through reading philosophy of science and reflecting at a deeper level on what scientists actually do that modern science cannot accomplish what originally attracted me to it. It cannot enable us to think nature as it is in itself. It cannot translate common sense experience of nature into knowledge of the way things really are. At best, it can explain one set of appearances perceived through the five senses in terms of another set of appearances also perceived through the five senses. This limit is obvious in the quintessential sciences of physics and chemistry. Sets of phenomena are related to other sets of phenomena by means of mathematical equations. We do not think the phenomena of nature; we observe them. We think only mathematical relationships.
Modern natural science—especially physics and chemistry—uses various techniques to perceive or multiply the phenomena of nature and relate them to each other via mathematics. Science does not make nature as we find it intelligible but dismembers it and reassembles it in thought—in mathematical thought, that is. At the risk of repetition, I want to emphasize this point: science disassembles naturally given wholes into parts, counts the parts, reassembles them in a mental model and then presents this accomplishment as an understanding the originally given whole.
Science as a Kind of Technology
Modern natural science, then, is a kind of technology. Let me explain further. In technology, we take things we find in nature and repurpose them for our own ends. We use a tree limb as a tool or a weapon. The more we learn about how natural materials behave under different circumstances, the greater the number of different kinds of machines we can make. Pure natural science is often distinguished from technology by asserting that it seeks knowledge of nature for knowledge’s sake alone whereas technology uses the knowledge gained through science to reconstruct nature to serve our purposes. I do not believe the distinction will hold up under examination.
It is true that natural science’s method aims at understanding the internal structures, external relationships and types of behaviors natural objects display. It does not aim (directly at least) at constructing new physical things for the sake of invention. But the “knowledge” science gains through its methods is not knowledge of the natural object as it is in itself. Scientific knowledge exists in the mind of the scientist as a mathematical equation or an imaginary model. That is to say, the scientist constructs something thinkable out of a naturally given object, which we cannot think in its natural state. And that process is a kind of technology.
Let Nature Speak!
I do not deny that modern natural science produces a kind of knowledge of nature. Describing the behaviors, relationships, and proportions of natural things gives us some insights into our world. Learning the quantitative relationships among natural phenomena, and discovering what conditions produce those phenomena gives us that sense of understanding that first attracted me to science. Such knowledge can be of practical use.
I am still curious; indeed, I am fascinated with what science can teach and may yet discover. But science cannot give us inside knowledge, knowledge of the whole natural thing—simultaneously and in its unity and integrity. And that is what a natural object truly is. That is what I’d like most to know!
Science interrogates, divides, crushes and uses nature. It talks incessantly. It can hear only its own voice and see only its own reflection.* If we are to know something of what nature truly is, we must be quiet, listen and wait. We must gaze and wonder in humility and reverence. Perhaps nature will speak. What language does it use, and what will it say?
In his Confessions, Augustine tells how he sought God in nature and what he found:
And what is the object of my love? I asked the earth and it said, “It is not I.” I asked all that is in it; they made the same confession…I asked the sea, the deeps, the living creatures that creep, and they responded, “We are not your God, look beyond us.” I asked the breezes which blow, and the entire air with its inhabitants said, “…I am not God.” I asked heaven, sun, moon, and stars; they said, “Nor are we the God whom you seek.” And I said to all these things in my external environment: “Tell me something of my God who you are not, tell me something about him.” And with one great voice they cried out: “He made us!” My question was the attention I gave to them, and their response was their beauty” (Book 10, vi; Chadwick translation, p. 183).
Fifteen centuries later the Scottish writer George MacDonald made a similar point:
In what belongs to the deeper meanings of nature and her mediation between us and God, the appearances of nature are the truths of nature, far deeper than any scientific discoveries concerning them. The show of things is that for which God cares most….It is through their show, not through their analysis, that we enter into their deepest truths. What they say to the childlike soul is the truest thing to be gathered of them. To know a primrose is a higher thing than to know all the botany of it—just as to know Christ is an infinitely higher thing than to know all theology, all that is said about His person, or babbled about His work. The body of man does not exist for the sake of its hidden secrets; its hidden secrets exist for the sake of its outside—for the face and the form in which dwells revelation: its outside is the deepest of it. So Nature as well exists primarily for her face, her look, her appeals to the heart and the imagination, her simple service to human need, and not for the secrets to be discovered in her and turned to man’s further use. (George McDonald in C.S. Lewis, ed., George McDonald: 365 Readings, 65).
And this is why I changed from science to theology. I did not know it then what I now know: all love, all curiosity, all desire, all wonder, and all knowing finds its true object and end only in God. I knew intuitively that I could never be satisfied with anything less.
*I am speaking of science as a method, not of the scientist who is also a human being and can simultaneously practice science and experience wonder.